Published on November 3rd, 20158
The Most Shocking Finding: Trans Fats in FCLO
Investigating Green Pasture Fermented Cod Liver Oil brought many surprises.1 The most publicized was my finding that it’s not cod liver oil at all, but pollock liver oil. That’s fired people up, but it’s a labeling issue, an integrity issue and a consumer’s “right to know” issue, more than a health issue. Given the product’s signature brown color and smell, I was saddened — but not particularly surprised — to learn it was in an advanced state of rancidity.
The shocker was finding trans fats:
- Trans fats of vegetable oil origin
- Trans fats of the type exposed in the late 1970s and warned against by the late Mary G. Enig, PhD
- Trans fats of the types linked to cancer, heart disease, reproductive problems and numerous other health problems
- Trans fats at 3.22 percent of total fatty acids, a level that exceeds the 2 percent limit allowed in food and supplements sold in Denmark and other European countries2
- Trans fats that are NOT remotely similar to the healthy CLA trans fats found in dairy
- Trans fats that the world’s leading marine oil scientists have never found in minimally processed fish liver oils.
But don’t take my word for it.
Here’s how a leading authority on fish oils, puts it:
No authentic raw or mildly processed cod liver oil will contain trans fats. There should also be none present if the cod liver oil is mildly refined. The presence of trans C18:3 indicates that another oil has been added to this oil. This other oil must obviously be in sufficient quantities to detect the presence of these trans fats.3
No authentic raw or mildly processed cod liver oil will contain trans fats. There should also be none present if the cod liver oil is mildly refined. The presence of trans C18:3 indicates that another oil has been added to this oil. This other oil must obviously be in sufficient quantities to detect the presence of these trans fats.
How can that be? First, a short chemistry lesson. The cis configuration in a naturally unsaturated fatty acid has hydrogen atoms on the same side of the carbons, resulting in a kink in the fatty acid chain. Partial hydrogenation of an oil, on the other hand, places hydrogen atoms on opposite sides of the carbon in a so-called trans configuration, causing the hydrocarbon chain to be relatively straight. The different shapes of cis and trans fatty acids have different physical properties, with artificially produced trans forms known to adversely affect human health.
Of the total 3.22 percent trans fats found in Green Pasture Fermented Cod Liver Oil, 2.40 percent was identified by a leading laboratory as an 18.3 trans fat.4 This type of trans fat could be the results of damage to a natural 18.3 cis alpha linolenic fat, which would be typically found in pollock liver oil at levels ranging from 0.4 to 0.7. However, the level of 18.3 cis found in FCLO by two laboratories came in at only 0.448 and 0.59, respectively. 5,6 Both are on par with the level typically found in pollock liver oil, which the 1998 Eagle Fisheries report states range from 0.4 to 0.7 percent.7
FCLO, however, contains 2.40 percent of 18.3 trans fat, a level that could only have been achieved by adding a thermally damaged vegetable oil. If the trans fats occurred because of heat damage to the fish liver oil itself during “fermentation” or other processing, the levels would be no higher than the level of 18:3 cis alpha.
FCLO also contains 18.1 trans fat at the level of 0.781 percent.8 Pollock liver oil contains 18.1cis, which is a form of oleic acid, at 15.4 to 26.5 percent. Fatty acid testing at two laboratories showed 18.1 cis in FCLO at the expected levels of 27.6 percent and 21.46 percent respectively.9,10 This suggests the 18.1 trans fat found in the sample of FCLO could be coming either from high heat during the processing of pollock liver oil OR from the addition of a thermally damaged oil.
Finally, FCLO contains an 18.2 trans fat at the level of 0.184 percent.11 This would be derived from an 18.2 cis linoleic acid, which is typically found in pollock liver oil at levels ranging from 0.7 to 1.0. Two laboratories testing for fatty acids reported the cis form at 1.12 percent and 0.94 percent respectively.12,13 This suggests it could be coming either from high heat during processing or from an added thermally damaged oil or from the 18.1 cis fat that is naturally present in pollock liver oil.
Is it from a vegetable oil? The presence of 2.40 percent trans fats of the 18.3 type says, yes. The presence of the 18.1 and 18.2 types of trans fats could be coming either from a vegetable oil or heat-damaged pollock oil.
Any way we look at it, no trans fats should be in FCLO
What does Chris Masterjohn PhD have to say about this. Not much. He begins by writing:
“I think it is worth noting that the lab test does not seem to distinguish whether the 18:3 trans is all trans, or is conjugated with alternating cis and trans double bonds. I think further elucidating the nature of the fatty acid may help shed light on where it comes.14
On first reading, this sounds impressive. But chemistry texts state that all eight trans isomers for 18.3 alpha linolenic acid result from the frying, deodorizing or partial hydrogenation of oils.15,16
In other words, none of them would legitimately be found in a fish liver oil.
As for Masterjohn’s request for “further elucidating the nature” of the 18.3 trans fats found, the laboratory breaks them down as follows:17
9T,12C,15T_18_3 9 trans, 12 cis, 15 trans of 18:3 trans-cis-trans
9C,12C,15T_18_3 9 cis , 12 cis, 15 trans of 18:3 cis-cis-trans
9C,12T,15T_18_3 9 cis, 12 trans, 15 trans of 18:3 cis-trans-trans
As stated above, all three of these are formed during the high heat processing or deodorization typical of commercial vegetable oil processing.
Could the trans fats in FCLO be the healthy CLA (Conjugated Linoleic Acid) that has beneficial effects for weight management, immune function, cancer, diabetes, and atherosclerosis? Fans of FCLO would like to think so, but the answer is “no.” CLA comes from cows and other ruminant animals, not fish. CLA is also identified as C9 t10, t11 or t12, none of which are showing up in FCLO’s fatty acid profiles. CLA is also not found in the extensive 1998 Eagle Fisheries report on pollock liver oil.18
Then could these trans fats come from any other source? Masterjohn offers the possibility of a trans fats produced by “fermentation” or microbial activity.19 To put this as politely as possible, this is far fetched — an explanation that could only serve his goal of exonerating Green Pasture and pleasing Sally Fallon Morell, president of the Weston A. Price Foundation and Masterjohn’s generous benefactor over the years.20 In the unlikely event that research ever shows 18.3 trans fats produced by fermentation or microbes, Green Pasture is not off the hook. Why, after all would anyone want to take a fish liver oil that contains 18:3s identical to those found in partially hydrogenated vegetable oils?
The most shocking finding about FCLO was trans fats, most likely of vegetable oil origin. There is no evidence that the trans fat found in FCLO represents a unique and special form of trans fats produced by Green Pasture’s “fermentation” process. Instead, the trans fats found match the trans fatty acids found in partially hydrogenated vegetable oils that have been linked through thousands of studies to cancer, heart disease and many other health problems. The National Academy of Sciences Institute of Medicine has concluded that the only safe level of such trans fats is zero.21
* * * * *
Has FCLO had an impact on your health? Please share.
Isn’t it time to read Hook, Line and Stinker: The Truth about Fermented Cod Liver Oil? Learn how lab tests show this product is rancid, low in fat-soluble vitamins . . . and not even cod! Click here to get your free download.
1. For laboratory data and full discussion, read my free report Hook, Line and Stinker: The Truth about Fermented Cod Liver Oil. http://drkaayladaniel.com/hook-line-and-stinker-opt-in/
2. Martin CA, Visentainer JV et al. Fatty acid contents of Brazilian soybeans oils with emphasis on trans fatty acids. Journal of the Brazilian Chemical Society, 2008, vol.19 no.1. http://dx.doi.org/10.1590/S0103-50532008000100017
3. Email correspondence with Dr. Gjermund Vogt, May 17 and July 6, 2015.
4. Data from Lab #1 in the appendix to the report Hook, Line and Stinker.
6. Data from Lab #7 in the appendix to the report Hook, Line and Stinker.
7. U.S. Market Prospects for Alaska Pollock Liver Oil. Eagle Fisheries, October 1998.http://bit.ly/1E2jifm
8. Data from Lab #1 in the appendix to the report Hook, Line and Stinker
10. Data from Lab #7 in the appendix to the report Hook, Line and Stinker.
11. Data from Lab #1 in the appendix to the report Hook, Line and Stinker
13. Data from Lab #7 in the appendix to the report Hook, Line and Stinker.
14. Masterjohn, Chris. Weighing in on the Fermented Cod Liver Oil (FCLO) Controversy, August 29, 2015. http://blog.cholesterol-and-health.com/2015/08/weighing-in-on-fermented-cod-liver-oil.html
15. Juaneda P. Utilization of silver-ion high performance liquid chromatography for separation of the geometrical isomers of a-Linolenic acid. Chapter 8 in New Trends in Lipids and Lipoprotein Analyses. J-L Sebedio, EG Perkins, eds. AOCS, 1995, pp. 75- 80.
16. Sebedio J-L, Christie WW. Metabolism of Trans Polyunsaturated Fatty Acids Formed during Frying, AOCS Lipid Laboratory. http://lipidlibrary.aocs.org/OilsFats/content.cfm?ItemNumber=39224
17. Trans fat breakdown provided September 3, 2015 by Laboratory #1 for Report Number: 1182753-0 Report Date: 27-Feb-2015 The Whole Nutritionist LLC. Project Id: WHOLE_NUTR-20150216-0001 Analysis of Fatty Acids. Trans fat breakdown
18. U.S. Market Prospects for Alaska Pollock Liver Oil. Eagle Fisheries, October 1998. http://bit.ly/1E2jifm
20. In his blog “Weighing in on the Fermented Cod Liver Oil (FCLO) Controversy,” Masterjohn acknowledges “potential conflicts of interest” because of his financial relationship with the Weston A. Price Foundation but he doesn’t give dollar figures. In addition to ongoing payments for writing, speaking and consulting, Masterjohn was paid an unknown amount for a semester of college courses prior to beginning his PhD program. He was also paid $89,000 for his post doc program at the University of Illinois, in addition to the $200,000 that went into the Burnsides Laboratory there. Masterjohn also gained an additional $30,000 — or “whatever he needs” in the words of Fallon Morell — to help set up a laboratory at Brooklyn College. Masterjohn may well have “total creative control” — as he claims— over what he writes for the Foundation and on his own blog, but it’s rather evident that Sally Fallon Morell and WAPF have oiled his career.
21. Letter report on dietary reference intakes for trans fatty acids. Food and Nutrition Board, Institute of Medicine, National Academy of Sciences, 2002.